Latest
Odd News

Deadlocked Atlantic Beach City Commission Race Decided by Coin Toss After 3,162–3,162 Tie

After machine and manual recounts left Jennifer Lagner and Lisa Herrold deadlocked at 3,162 votes apiece for Atlantic Beach City Commission Seat 4, Duval County election officials settled the race with a best-of-three coin toss.

Read the story
Odd News · Read the story
Newstro Odd News section banner.
Newstro
Share this story

A challenge coin breaks a 3,162-vote deadlock in Florida

Atlantic Beach, Fla. — November 20, 2026 · 12:10 p.m. CST (18:10 UTC).

Every ballot in Atlantic Beach’s Seat 4 city commission race was counted, recounted by machine, and recounted again by hand—and when the final tally came back, candidates Jennifer Lagner and Lisa Herrold were still tied at exactly 3,162 votes apiece.

With no more ballots left to break the impasse, Duval County Supervisor of Elections Jerry Holland turned to a tiebreaker allowed under Florida election law: a best-of-three coin flip, according to Fox News and the New York Post.

Standing outside the Duval County Supervisor of Elections office on November 13, Holland tossed an “America 250” challenge coin onto a square mat. Lagner took the first two flips cleanly, winning 2–0 without needing a third toss, The Inquisitr and the Times of India reported.

How the best-of-three coin flip played out

Before the toss began, election officials set simple ground rules: each candidate would alternate calling the flip, and the coin had to land flat inside the center of the square mat on the ground for the toss to count.

Herrold called heads on the opening flip, but the challenge coin came up tails, giving Lagner the first point. Lagner then called heads on the second toss, and the coin landed on heads—sealing the 2–0 victory in roughly 20 seconds.

The race had remained unresolved through the post-election canvass after both machine and manual recounts confirmed the identical 3,162-vote totals. Even a late-arriving overseas ballot failed to break the deadlock because the voter left the Seat 4 commission contest blank.

Why Florida law settles tied elections by lot

While municipal races rarely end in exact ties after more than 6,300 ballots are cast, Florida statutes provide for tied elections to be decided by “lot”—a game of chance such as drawing names or flipping a coin—once recounts and provisional or overseas ballots are exhausted.

For Atlantic Beach voters, the outcome underscored how razor-thin local turnout and ballot choices can be: a single vote in either direction—or one marked selection on the blank overseas ballot—would have spared both campaigns a trip to the coin mat.

Where the deadlocked race took place

Atlantic Beach is a coastal municipality in Duval County, east of downtown Jacksonville, where the Duval County Supervisor of Elections office conducted the recount and tiebreaker.

★ Atlantic Beach, Florida, whose City Commission Seat 4 race ended in a 3,162–3,162 tie before being decided by a coin toss in Duval County. Map data: OpenStreetMap contributors, ODbL. Open map.

Timeline from Election Day to the coin flip

  1. — Voters in Atlantic Beach cast ballots in the general election for City Commission Seat 4 between Jennifer Lagner and Lisa Herrold.
  2. — Machine and manual recounts overseen by Duval County Supervisor of Elections Jerry Holland confirm an exact tie at 3,162 votes each; a received overseas ballot is blank in the race.
  3. — Lagner wins a best-of-three coin toss 2–0 outside the Duval County Supervisor of Elections office to claim the Seat 4 victory.

Sources and visual credits

Sources: Fox News, New York Post, The Inquisitr, and Times of India.

Visuals: Newstro.