A challenge coin breaks a 3,162-vote deadlock in Florida
Atlantic Beach, Fla. — November 20, 2026 · 12:10 p.m. CST (18:10 UTC).
Every ballot in Atlantic Beach’s Seat 4 city commission race was counted, recounted by machine, and recounted again by hand—and when the final tally came back, candidates Jennifer Lagner and Lisa Herrold were still tied at exactly 3,162 votes apiece.
With no more ballots left to break the impasse, Duval County Supervisor of Elections Jerry Holland turned to a tiebreaker allowed under Florida election law: a best-of-three coin flip, according to Fox News and the New York Post.
Standing outside the Duval County Supervisor of Elections office on November 13, Holland tossed an “America 250” challenge coin onto a square mat. Lagner took the first two flips cleanly, winning 2–0 without needing a third toss, The Inquisitr and the Times of India reported.
